Last Thursday, Shift attended a hearing at the Ontario Superior Court to support the four young Canadians who are suing the Canada Pension Plan Investment Board (CPPIB).
The young people allege that CPPIB is failing its legal obligations to protect the long-term interests of Canada Pension Plan (CPP) contributors and beneficiaries by inadequately managing climate-related financial risks while investing billions in fossil fuel expansion. The young Canadians – Aliya Hirji, Chloe Tse, Rav Singh and Travis Olson – launched the lawsuit in October 2025, and finally got their day in court over a year later.
The young litigants are not seeking financial compensation. They are asking the court to recognize that CPPIB has a legal duty to manage climate risks in the best interests of CPP contributors and beneficiaries. CPPIB is seeking to have the case dismissed, making the extraordinary argument that it owes no fiduciary duty to those four young people – or any of the 22 million Canadians whose retirement savings it manages.
Read on to learn more about this landmark climate lawsuit getting its first day in court.
Canada Pension Plan members and climate advocates gathered outside Ontario Superior Court on Thursday November 12, 2026. Photos by Joshua Best.
Canadians gathered to support these brave young people
It was a cold, rainy morning in Toronto, but Shift joined retirees, climate advocates, labour allies, young workers and other CPP members before the hearing in a show of support for the young litigants outside the court house.
Chloe Tse – one of the applicants, who will not be eligible to receive CPP benefits until 2066 – addressed the crowd of supporters, explaining that she wanted to understand how an institution responsible for her pension savings was preparing for a changing climate that would drastically impact her future retirement security in an economy and financial system that could be destabilized by climate change.
Chloe was joined by Krista Laing, a young outdoor worker, chair of the CUPE Ontario Municipal Workers Committee, and president of the Durham Region Labour Council. Krista talked about how the climate crisis is already creating risks for her job and her livelihood, and how the investment decisions being made by CPPIB today will have a direct impact on her financial security in the future.
Joined by her colleagues from CUPE Ontario’s Climate Justice Committee, Krista called for intergenerational fairness, saying that “I'm contributing to my pension today because I expect it to be there when I retire. CPPIB has a responsibility to protect that future, not put it at risk.”
Speakers included Adam Scott, Executive Director of Shift, Chlose Tse, applicant in the case, and Krista Laing, CPP contributor, young municipal worker, and president of the Durham Region Labour Council. Photos by Joshua Best.
In a show of intergenerational solidarity, Krista and Chloe were joined by Lee Ramsey, a CPP beneficiary and retired librarian. Lee called for CPPIB to start taking climate change seriously, demanding responsible pension management, transparency and accountability: “At the very least, it should be obvious that CPPIB shouldn’t use our retirement savings to make the climate crisis even worse by making risky investments in pipelines, gas plants and LNG terminals.”
Speakers included Lee Ramsey, CPP beneficiary and retired public librarian, and Charlie Hatt, Climate Program Director, Ecojustice, the environmental law charity representing the applicants in the legal challenge. Photos by Joshua Best.
Canadians packed the court room
We then walked to the Ontario Superior Court to attend the hearing, where every seat in the court’s public viewing area was filled with CPP contributors and beneficiaries who showed up to support the young Canadians.
Despite the technical and procedural nature of the hearing, Canadians listened intently as lawyers for CPPIB began the day with an extraordinary legal argument: in an attempt to prevent the climate lawsuit from proceeding to trial, CPPIB is claiming that it does not owe a fiduciary duty to the young Canadian applicants – or to any CPP contributors and beneficiaries.
In response to CPPIB’s argument, Ecojustice lawyer Karine Peloffy, one of the lawyers representing the young Canadian litigants, said “CPP Investments was created to ensure the Canada Pension Plan would be viable for future generations. Yet rather than answer for its alleged failure to prudently manage climate-related financial risks, it is taking the extraordinary and insupportable position that it owes no duties whatsoever to young contributors. This position is untenable, and the motion to strike should be dismissed.”
While a transcript or recording of the hearing is not available, attendees sat quietly as lawyers for CPPIB made a series of arguments in their attempt to prevent the case from advancing to trial on its merits. At one point, the courtroom gasped as a CPPIB lawyer claimed that the impacts of climate change were “unknowable,” and compared the unequivocal urgency and severity of the climate crisis to “religious dogma.” At another point, the judge challenged CPPIB lawyers to explain why CPPIB’s board is incapable of requiring the pension manager to develop a climate-aligned investment framework. CPPIB lawyers even claimed that the young litigants were trying to impose a political agenda on the pension plan, arguing that somehow their demand for climate accountability undermined the pension of an oil sands worker.
The young litigants are doing no such thing. They are simply asking the court to recognize that CPPIB has a legal duty to manage climate risks, like all other material financial risks, in the best interests of CPP contributors and beneficiaries.
What’s next?
The hearing was scheduled to continue the next day, but the judge indicated that she understood the legal arguments of both sides, and ended the hearing without needing to reconvene the following day. The judge “reserved” her decision. That means that she will take some time to weigh the arguments made by each side and provide a ruling on CPPIB’s motion to strike the case in the near future, likely in several weeks.
While Shift is not a party to this lawsuit, we are following the case closely. We will provide news and updates on the case as we learn more.
In the meantime, CPPIB is hosting its national virtual meeting on Thursday, November 19th. Submit a question now about the extraordinary claim CPPIB made in this hearing: Why does CPPIB believe that it doesn’t have a fiduciary duty to you, me and over 22 million other CPP members?